Soccerlens.com

I strongly disagree with your opinions regarding Evra and Smith.

Evra, this season, has proven that he is by no means a failure, and I was one of the people slating him as another bad signing by Fergie last year. How he proved us wrong. Defensively, I still think he has a lot to learn, but going forward and attacking the wing he’s proven his worth and his pace is as good as Neville on the right hand side. Even if he has questionable judgement at the back from time to time, I think he’s learning (he was a striker after all) the trade still, but is easily my first choice for left back. Heinze has been lacklustre since the world cup and a player of his calibre can’t use the old “I’ve been out injured” excuse. He should have been sent of twice and given away about four penalties in the last two months of the season, but got away with it. If the ref had seen fit to award those penalties, would we still be in love with the Argentine? I doubt it.

As for Smithie, he deserves to stay for no other reason than his dogged resilience in coming back from that horrific injury. He was used sparingly when he came back to fitness and proved in the few chances he had at the end that he can be a very effective replacement in the last 20 minutes. He didn’t have a lot of luck in front of goal, but when he was given the ball in a scoring position, he made it tell. The goal against Roma was a cracking team goal, but well finished from a guy who’d been out of the game for nigh on 12 months.

In my mind, Richardson, Heinze and Saha are out this year. Heinze will go to Spain, Saha back to France (or another Premiership outfit) and Richardson will go to either Sunderland or Sheffield United.

Smith should stay. Think if both Saha and Ole get injured again. Then we definetly need smudge. he is maybe better than any other backup player we have. You cant compare him to Rooney, Berbatov, Torres….. he maybe isnt as deadly as them, but he bring something special to the squad. And all the time I only hear: Smith is not that quick, Smith is not thatdeadly as Drogba, He cant score 25-30 goals a season… But think of his streangth, his aggresion, his heading and passing + Unego he has.

Smith is simply too old to go out on loan…he’d never agree to that. He should either be kept as a decent back-up or sold. I’m torn on this issue, because I really like his character. On the other hand he could bring in a tidy sum with his return to the national team and all.

As it seems, we’re not after a striker in this window, and because of that we should probably keep him another year. Next summer we’ll have to go for a striker, and then we could sell him to get some cash back…or part of a swap deal, although I don’t see us getting a striker from England, and I doubt Smith wants to go abroad. We’d probably get £7-8 mil for him, which could ease the purchase of Torres (did I really mention him) or Eto’o next summer.

Richardson should be sold – no question about it. Silvestre should go as well, and he’d bring in a good sum (£4-5 mil) on merrits alone. Sell Eagles (£2-3 mil), who has no future at OT either with the new signings. That’s how we buy 3 major prospects and get rid of 3, who aren’t even close to the team, for £40 mil.

Richardson and silvestre should be sold then buy a good striker

why do we forget solskjear and giggs?to me the worst players considering they get too much playing time,underperform and we have to attack young guns who have room 4 imrovement?

Mike – what are you on? Giggs was excellent last season, many suggested he was a candidate for player of the year!! Ole should be kept as he is now an institution at the club, a great ambassador, with lots of experience to pass on. And he can still finish. Too much playing time? How much did Ole get last year? Not much at all!!

Oh, come on now, leave Smith alone. He is seriously underrated, especially by his own fans. The man suffered a horrible injury(there was a keeper once who retired after a similar injury). Not only did Smith return, he was great in his what, 5-6 games he managed to play last season. It’s not that he had too much time to prove himself, and hopefully he’ll get it next term. So, get of his case, and besides, sir Alex has always held him in high regard. And please, cut it out with the age thing, Pippo Inzaghi is the same age as Giggsy and 2Olegend and that didn’t stop him from winning the CL for the wops.

What about OShea? He is by far the worst player in MU, not to mention in the Premiership…

Evra is worthy to be at Man U. Very talented. Why the hell get Bale?

BTW, I heart Spurs.

Tom – I agree with many of your tips, but 2.

Number 4 – I assume you mean Nani and Anderson when writing “youngsters”. Ronaldo was 17, when he joined…these guys are 19 and 20, so it won’t take them as long time to settle. I think that 3 or 4 months into the season we’ll start to see, what we’ve bought, which is pure class. They may not be as consistant in the coming season, as we’d like them to be, but there’s room for that…as long as they will be the season after that, when they need to step up as first choices on their positions.

Number 9 – there’s so much talk about Saha’s lack of heart…couldn’t he just be plain injured?? The thing is – it’s all media speculation that SAF should be tired of Saha not playing due to a weak mind, and that has transformed into the fans not believing in him either. Saha has always had injury problems, and he always will have them. He was absolutely brilliant in the first half of the season and scored some spectacular and very important goals.

Great topic!

My assessment of the players in question.

Richardson, I think we can all agree that aside from blistering pace and a sweet left foot (occasionally), he brings very little to a game. Greedy beyond belief, no vision, cant tackle etc., etc., etc. GOT TO GO.
Sylvestre, has been a good solid player over the years but his recent tendancy to completely lose track of the game around him is too risky. Great going forward sometimes, but mostly a liability. GOT TO GO.
Heinze, has been a star for us. I love his style of no nonsense defending, rock solid most of the time. Had a patchy end of season after another injury but its completely unfair to blame him for the Milan result. He plays his heart out. Ive read the quotes on ManUtd.com and they are taken from a bigger interview, so you dont know what the context is, im sure he could be saying that IF he leaves he doesn’t know yet whether it will be Madrid or Barca. He has also openly stated how happy he is in Manchester and that he has played the best fotty of his career here, so its best not to read too much into snippets of interviews. KEEP HIM. is say.
Giggs, Totally off his game for me since early new year. Maybe fatigue, but whatever the reason, below par at the end. No question of him leaving though, will share his role with Nani more this year. PHASE HIM OUT
Smith, He can stay, excellent work ethic and totally committed to the cause. A great example to the youngsters on what it takes to make it at United, despite his lack of first team action. Still a role for him in the team too. KEEP HIM.
Fletcher, Im not sure if he has done enough. Has got loads of energy, no doubt. Other than that? Not much apart from lack of pace, no awareness, can’t tackle or retain posession and his passing is best described as poor. Fergie must see something in him. GOT TO GO
Ole is not gonna go, he’ll move into coaching soon at OT. Not sure how much we’ll see Anderson this year, i kinda thought we’d see more Nani, but i could be wrong there.
Thats the lot, long winded i know, but if any of you can be arsed to read it, let me know what you think.

I guess we just have to agree to disagree, Ahmed.
Regarding Gabriel Heinze; could you please tell me why you think he is the best man for United at left back?

Silvestre – He should definitely NOT stay at united but I am nearly 80% sure tht he will because Ferguson sees him as a loyal back-up player, but when he comes into the team he probably has a 40% chance of giving away a penalty with the amount he has given away in the amount of games he has played(i think hes given away three penalties)
Heinze – He’s still a very good player and I think we should keep him, but if he’s not first choice and real madrid or barca are looking at him im sure it would be hard to say no, as he would be their first choice left back, almost definitely.
O’Shea – Well he’s nothing spectacular but in times of many injuries/suspensions we will need him to fill in in many positions. And he’s gauranteed to give you a few important goals a season(Aresnal 2 years ago, liverpool this year, and others)
Evra – He is a great left back and is definitely good enough to be our left back – as is heinze – so he shouldn’ be sold.
Richardson – Ok he has a good shot from range, but he’s a terrible finisher, not a particulary good tackler, has no skills at all (even giggs can do more) and we have better players in any position he plays (CM,LB and LM)
Saha- He is good enough and a great player whemn he’s playing, but having an injury prone striker is frustrating and if he continues to have injury problems or be sitting on the bench then his value will drop, sell him now (for 7m?
)
Smith – I definitely like him, and he plays well if we play him as our top striker in a 4-3-2-1 but he just won’t play enought games and he deserves to be playing first team football, at a team like bolton maybe?
I would also like to say i’m very excited about seeing anderson and nani but anderson said that his favourite position is left back =S in an interview on manutd.com he said something like:
‘I can play in many positions, behind the striker, on the left of the midfield, but my favourite position is an attacking left back, the position that roberto carlos plays for brazil, and i have played their before for my team.’
that was basically it.

ok ahmed true that we dont have back ups…but dont you think that fergie could buy with the money he gets from the imminent heinze sale a good promising left back like leighton baines…

Well i strongly disagree with your view concerning Evra. This fella has been top class last season and played a strong part in the title run-in. Yeah he needs to get tougher and improve his tackling but remember he’s still only 23/24. so he’s bound to get better next season. Now that Man U have a good holding midfielder like Hargreaves an adventurous full back will NOT be surplus to requirements.
Moreover Heinz is pushing 29 and he is considerably slower and more injury prone now. he’s not the same player as he was before his injury. Its sad but i think it may be a good idea to cash on him now before he gets even slower.

As for Fletcher, I’d love to see him stay one more year but i guess for his own good he will have to consider moving on sooner or later. i agree that he needs to become more devilish and aggressive. This guy is talented though and i’m sure that, if given time to develop, he can become a very good and effective midfielder. Just he wont get many chances with United now.

Smith has to stay no question!!!

Giggs is not even disscussable (if such a word exists!!). he’s an untouchable legend and now that we have new players he will be able to get as much rest as he needs between games. Same applies to Scholes and Solksjaer. and if Pique or Lee are as good as we hear then Neville will also get some rest from time to time. You know money can buy everything bar experience, wisdom and commitment!!

The definite outs should be Richardson and Silvestre.

we will suffer a lot if we dont get another left back and we sold gabi ihope that dosent happen
but unfourunatly it looks like its going to happen
ANELKA he is the perfect addition to our squad and also he is cheap

anelka, our cantona!