Frank Lampard vs Steven Gerrard – Who’s Better?

These two marvelous midfield Maestros would waltz their way into any team in Europe, but are both inconsistent on the international scene.

Following on from Ed Harrison’s argument that these two superstars of the premiership should not be guaranteed a starting place in the England line up, which one of these players would YOU pick should McClaren leave one out to give the team more balance?

For the basis of my argument, I will settle the matter comparing attributes which all midfielders need in their arsenal, rather like a game of TOP TRUMPS. I have given them a rating out of 10 for each attribute. Here it goes…( I know that many of you will disagree!)

GERRARD LAMPARD

Skill 8 8

Passing 9 9

Leadership 10 8

Shooting 8 10

Tackling 9 7

Defending 8 7

Speed 9 8

As You can see, Gerrard just shades it scoring 61/70 with Lampard achieving 57/70.

In a game of Top trumps, Gerrard would only be ‘Gazumped’ by Lampard in his shooting ability. Off topic slightly, how many other midfielders in Europe would score as consistently high across the board as Gerrard? Sure, there are those who are more sublime in the pass, stronger in the tackle, faster and better at shooting. But he has no weak aspect to his game. He can play central midfield (as a holding or attacking player), in the whole just behind the srikers, as a right winger and also as a makeshift right back or centre half.

Therefore (in my slightly biased opinion!), I rate him as the most complete midfield player in Europe…with Fatty Lumplard a close second. In fact why should McClaren leave one out? He should give them both a kick up the arse and demand that they get their act together. It would be such a waste otherwise.

Does anybody agree?

Liverpool takeover financed by 298m loans, but it's all OK
Manchester United vs Europe XI - Videos (Beck's return, Ronaldo's free kick, etc)

316 Comments

  1. Sam 14 March, 2007
  2. magnumopus 14 March, 2007
  3. Mark Hobbs 14 March, 2007
  4. Dexter 14 March, 2007
  5. Sid 14 March, 2007
  6. Ian 14 March, 2007
  7. Carl 14 March, 2007
  8. Tippers 14 March, 2007
  9. drew.dinneen 14 March, 2007
  10. Kit 14 March, 2007
  11. Kopite 14 March, 2007
  12. This is Pointless 14 March, 2007
  13. rouman 14 March, 2007
  14. nick 14 March, 2007
  15. Alex 14 March, 2007
  16. Ed Harrison 14 March, 2007
  17. ste price 14 March, 2007
  18. Andrei MEZA 15 March, 2007
  19. Karl 15 March, 2007
  20. ste price 15 March, 2007
  21. Andrew 15 March, 2007
  22. Keith Kaira II 16 March, 2007
  23. Andrew 17 March, 2007
  24. kaan 18 March, 2007
  25. Andrew 19 March, 2007
  26. DBeech 19 March, 2007
  27. DBeech 19 March, 2007
  28. MDH 24 March, 2007
  29. Nethappy 28 March, 2007
  30. charmaine 25 April, 2007
  31. Ahmed Bilal 25 April, 2007
  32. Keith Kaira II 25 April, 2007
  33. DM 27 April, 2007
  34. Ahmed Bilal 27 April, 2007
  35. aaron foster 3 May, 2007
  36. mahmoud egypt 3 May, 2007
  37. David 22 May, 2007
  38. Nausherwan Saeem 24 May, 2007
  39. Allen 24 May, 2007
  40. David 27 May, 2007
  41. David 27 May, 2007
  42. David 27 May, 2007
  43. David 27 May, 2007
  44. Ifeanyi 28 May, 2007
  45. Ahmed Umair 28 May, 2007
  46. Sadat 28 May, 2007
  47. carl 28 May, 2007
  48. Craigg 28 May, 2007
  49. Dave 28 2 June, 2007
  50. kakalegend 2 June, 2007
  51. kakalegend 2 June, 2007
  52. BootifullGame 3 June, 2007
  53. nelly 7 June, 2007
  54. Brook 7 June, 2007
  55. lady beautiful 8 June, 2007
  56. sani 8 June, 2007
  57. ASB 8 June, 2007
  58. Andrei Meza 20 June, 2007
  59. MARINA GABRIEL 20 June, 2007
  60. Asadullah Anees Khan 20 June, 2007
  61. karl 20 June, 2007
  62. liam 28 June, 2007
  63. Raju 28 June, 2007
  64. spizzy 28 June, 2007
  65. toq 28 June, 2007
  66. demonrho 28 June, 2007
  67. Chelsea Fan 1 July, 2007
  68. Andrew 6 July, 2007
  69. Cantona = GOD 7 July, 2007
  70. david 9 July, 2007
  71. NO COMMENT 26 July, 2007
  72. mark o 15 August, 2007
  73. davie 15 August, 2007
  74. davie 15 August, 2007
  75. davie 15 August, 2007
  76. davie 15 August, 2007
  77. steven 21 August, 2007
  78. jackg 21 August, 2007
  79. Me 22 August, 2007
  80. nigeria 22 August, 2007
  81. Liverpool_Fan 23 August, 2007
  82. Strikarz 23 August, 2007
  83. Kramster 23 August, 2007
  84. David 23 August, 2007
  85. Liverpool_Fan 23 August, 2007
  86. David 27 August, 2007
  87. David 27 August, 2007
  88. Kramster 27 August, 2007
  89. coolchic 27 August, 2007
  90. smartass gunner 27 August, 2007
  91. Liverpool_Fan 27 August, 2007
  92. Liverpool_Fan 27 August, 2007
  93. Strikarz 27 August, 2007
  94. smartass gunner 27 August, 2007
  95. olamilekan 28 August, 2007
  96. Liverpool_Fan 28 August, 2007
  97. Cris f 28 August, 2007
  98. Cris f 28 August, 2007
  99. aatir 28 August, 2007
  100. aatir 28 August, 2007
  101. manutd jaluo 28 August, 2007
  102. David 30 August, 2007
  103. David 30 August, 2007
  104. mr X 30 August, 2007
  105. Kramster 30 August, 2007
  106. Kramster 31 August, 2007
  107. corey 31 August, 2007
  108. kush 31 August, 2007
  109. Liverpool_Fan 31 August, 2007
  110. Liverpool_Fan 31 August, 2007
  111. david 2 September, 2007
  112. david 2 September, 2007
  113. MDH 2 September, 2007
  114. Liverpool_Fan 2 September, 2007
  115. david 3 September, 2007
  116. jack 4 September, 2007
  117. Liverpool_Fan 5 September, 2007
  118. Salim 5 September, 2007
  119. nerazzurri 5 September, 2007
  120. Ian J 5 September, 2007
  121. Ian J 5 September, 2007
  122. Liverpool_Fan 5 September, 2007
  123. Liverpool_Fan 5 September, 2007
  124. NiKOS 5 September, 2007
  125. Karl 5 September, 2007
  126. Liverpool_Fan 5 September, 2007
  127. Karl 5 September, 2007
  128. Liverpool_Fan 5 September, 2007
  129. Brian B 5 September, 2007
  130. Liverpool_Fan 6 September, 2007
  131. david 6 September, 2007
  132. Liverpool_Fan 6 September, 2007
  133. david 7 September, 2007
  134. david 7 September, 2007
  135. david 7 September, 2007
  136. david 7 September, 2007
  137. Liverpool_Fan 7 September, 2007
  138. Fifth Column 7 September, 2007
  139. david 7 September, 2007
  140. david 7 September, 2007
  141. Karl 7 September, 2007
  142. Brian B 7 September, 2007
  143. Liverpool_Fan 8 September, 2007
  144. Kramster 29 September, 2007
  145. David 1 October, 2007
  146. Liverpool_Fan 2 October, 2007
  147. madimetja 4 October, 2007
  148. vincent 16 October, 2007
  149. Brian W 16 October, 2007
  150. Kramster 16 October, 2007
  151. Andrei 16 October, 2007
  152. Liverpool_Fan 16 October, 2007
  153. Liverpool_Fan 17 October, 2007
  154. David 18 October, 2007
  155. David 18 October, 2007
  156. Brian W 18 October, 2007
  157. Liverpool_Fan 18 October, 2007
  158. Jenny 18 October, 2007
  159. sam h 19 October, 2007
  160. Brian W 19 October, 2007
  161. Rui J. 19 October, 2007
  162. Liverpool_Fan 19 October, 2007
  163. Brian W 19 October, 2007
  164. Liverpool_Fan 20 October, 2007
  165. Brian W 20 October, 2007
  166. Liverpool_Fan 20 October, 2007
  167. Brian W 20 October, 2007
  168. Liverpool_Fan 21 October, 2007
  169. manutd fan 25 October, 2007
  170. LFC 28 October, 2007
  171. LFC 28 October, 2007
  172. Brian W 28 October, 2007
  173. Liverpool_Fan 29 October, 2007
  174. Cheeseman 29 October, 2007
  175. Liverpool_Fan 29 October, 2007
  176. Gooner4ever 30 October, 2007
  177. Louis 5 November, 2007
  178. louis 5 November, 2007
  179. Liverpool_Fan 5 November, 2007
  180. sinead 28 November, 2007
  181. Nerazzurri 28 November, 2007
  182. Andrei Meza 28 November, 2007
  183. David 1 December, 2007
  184. paul kelly 6 December, 2007
  185. will 9 December, 2007
  186. jason 15 December, 2007
  187. fernando henrique lopes 2 January, 2008
  188. Shaun Daley 2 January, 2008
  189. Ahmed Bilal 3 January, 2008
  190. Karl 3 January, 2008
  191. kyle mckee 9 January, 2008
  192. kyle mckee 9 January, 2008
  193. MARK 9 January, 2008
  194. Sean 18 January, 2008
  195. Liverpool_Fan 19 January, 2008
  196. Liverpool_Fan 19 January, 2008
  197. Liverpool_Fan 19 January, 2008
  198. Brian W 19 January, 2008
  199. Liverpool_Fan 20 January, 2008
  200. David 2 February, 2008
  201. andy, lfc 6 February, 2008
  202. Karl 6 February, 2008
  203. James 17 February, 2008
  204. Liverpool_Fan 18 February, 2008
  205. JON 14 March, 2008
  206. ROBBIE 14 March, 2008
  207. nihblk 18 March, 2008
  208. sian 20 March, 2008
  209. Felix Navidad 12 April, 2008
  210. Zed 29 April, 2008
  211. George 1 May, 2008
  212. hamoudi 26 May, 2008
  213. Igor from russia 4 June, 2008
  214. gerrad azam 6 June, 2008
  215. seddak 28 September, 2008
  216. Ken 5 October, 2008
  217. betty 6 October, 2008
  218. Johnson 7 October, 2008
  219. Brad 7 October, 2008
  220. Brad 7 October, 2008
  221. Brad 7 October, 2008
  222. Stwefano 7 October, 2008
  223. Rick 9 October, 2008
  224. Stwefano 9 October, 2008
  225. LondonBob 13 October, 2008
  226. WE'VE GOT CESC FABREGAS 13 October, 2008
  227. WE'VE GOT CESC FABREGAS 13 October, 2008
  228. Nalin 23 October, 2008
  229. Johnson 29 October, 2008
  230. hypester28 29 October, 2008
  231. FOOTBALL!! 26 November, 2008
  232. Diego 5 December, 2008
  233. Arvyn 12 December, 2008
  234. tolu 17 December, 2008
  235. Viva Ronaldo 20 December, 2008
  236. Lady Scouse 20 December, 2008
  237. FOOTY FAN 20 December, 2008
  238. FOOTY FAN 20 December, 2008
  239. wax 24 December, 2008
  240. vessago 30 December, 2008
  241. NoOne 30 December, 2008
  242. zayne 30 December, 2008
  243. THE PAPACY, ghana 5 January, 2009
  244. moin 28 January, 2009
  245. Jack 3 February, 2009
  246. Paul 4 February, 2009
  247. Statsman 12 March, 2009
  248. Yomi Akinyemi 13 March, 2009
  249. zoykriosis 29 March, 2009
  250. zoykriosis 29 March, 2009
  251. Sami 31 March, 2009
  252. Sullivan 16 April, 2009
  253. dan lar 16 April, 2009
  254. Frenchman 17 April, 2009
  255. Frenchman 17 April, 2009
  256. Sullivan 18 April, 2009
  257. Frenchman 19 April, 2009
  258. rido 22 April, 2009
  259. Sullivan 25 April, 2009
  260. Sullivan 26 April, 2009
  261. brandon 5 May, 2009
  262. dan lar 14 May, 2009
  263. Andrew 15 May, 2009
  264. Sam 15 May, 2009
  265. waiting 30 May, 2009
  266. ibrar 31 May, 2009
  267. chris 3 June, 2009
  268. chelsea_fan 20 June, 2009
  269. Luke Mjstc 20 June, 2009
  270. dan lar 23 June, 2009
  271. Dom 24 June, 2009
  272. tyler 27 June, 2009
  273. Tarek 10 July, 2009
  274. Anna 16 July, 2009
  275. Kieran 1 August, 2009
  276. ..jl17 3 September, 2009
  277. mustafa omar 8 September, 2009
  278. Jonski 10 September, 2009
  279. joshua 25 September, 2009
  280. danlar 8 October, 2009
  281. SuperFrank 13 October, 2009
  282. Mr Lfc Man 89 21 October, 2009
  283. bollox 30 October, 2009
  284. princesoso 28 November, 2009
  285. Amritpal Singh 7 December, 2009
  286. ERNEST 23 December, 2009
  287. PRAVEEN NAIR 29 December, 2009
  288. Usama 3 January, 2010
  289. Alan 10 January, 2010
  290. Peter Holt 1 February, 2010
  291. Toffee T 2 February, 2010
  292. zobs 15 February, 2010
  293. aaron 23 February, 2010
  294. tam88 26 February, 2010
  295. Jerry Van Buyten 1 March, 2010
  296. Jerry Van Buyten 1 March, 2010
  297. souravmoy 6 March, 2010
  298. Me 12 March, 2010
  299. nick 16 March, 2010
  300. Obinna 08062553244 27 March, 2010
  301. arsenal fan 28 March, 2010
  302. Thave 26 April, 2010
  303. Jonh 7 May, 2010
  304. master footballer 23 May, 2010
    • mm 26 May, 2010
  305. 8 for ever 26 May, 2010
  306. Chelsea 4 June, 2010
  307. gopu 9 June, 2010
  308. MYI 13 June, 2010
  309. :) 13 June, 2010
  310. Leigh 15 June, 2010
  311. jalal 22 July, 2010
  312. LfC 27 July, 2010
  313. chelsea kid 2 15 August, 2010
  314. Deepak 17 August, 2010
  315. kkk 19 August, 2010