Oct
31
2008

What would it take for you to leave your dream club?

Written by Luke Smith

luke-and-adebayor
Do you really love the greedy bastards?

The majority of us have one. A personal vendetta with a man you’ve never met. A man who could not have done much worse had he slept with your wife.

These are the players that rinse your club for every last penny. The players that see your club as a stepping stone or proclaim their undying love one week only to sulk and talk themselves into a move the next.

For Spurs see Dimitar Berbatov, Arsenal; Ashley Cole, Liverpool had Michael Owen and I think some would even put Chelsea’s Frank Lampard in that category.

Now I’m sure many Spurs, Arsenal, Liverpool and Chelsea fans are nodding their heads in agreement with me here, but the question I’d like to ask is to what extent do you empathise with the men after the money?

As an Arsenal supporter myself I lend only complete and utter disdain towards Ashley Cole and his character, irrespective of whether there is 3 lions on his chest or a solitary blue one.

I boo his very appearance upon my television, cheer any tackle on him and rejoice in sordid tales surrounding his troubled personal life (though I think that has more to do with my hope Cheryl will come knocking on my door one day) .

As for the controversy surrounding his booing at Wembley against Kazakhstan, I could only laugh. Far from worrying about the effect this could have on a fickle England sides confidence, I instead saw it as confirmation of his status as England’s most hated player.

For, whatever your affinity with Arsenal, be it good or bad, you can empathise with us based purely on the way Cole set about his dirty business.

Whilst in a Waterstones book outlet yesterday I faced the dilemma of picking up his autobiography, purely out of curiosity. As it was I settled with leaving it, knowing I wouldn’t be wasting my time on a figure I so loath. As it is I have selected a couple of quotes that depict a pretty desperate defence:

‘I’m not asking for sympathy — just an awareness of what’s gone on, how I didn’t want to leave and how I feel the board messed things up. Not me. This situation couldn’t have just been my fault. I’m not disloyal. I’m a loyal and honest person and I’ve got principles. I can wake up in the morning and look at myself in the mirror, knowing that I’ve done no wrong. I tried to be fair. I tried to be decent. I wonder if the Arsenal board could say the same?’

‘The deal he offered was a £10,000-a-week increase to £35,000. A hell of a lot of money. But, when taken in the context of football wages and his own estimated value of me of £20 million, and when placed next to those other Arsenal wages of between £80,000 and £100,000 a week, his offer was a p*ss-take. It was a slap in the face, not a pat on the back.’

And people are surprised as to why he gets booed.

Now, I know that some of you will be reading this and thinking 1) get over it and 2) how childishly my opinion manifests itself. However, my passion for Arsenal far outweighs my sense of logic in this instance.

And that’s what makes it so hard to understand where Ashley was coming from when stating his reasons behind wanting to leave.

‘When I heard Jonathan (Barnett) repeat the figure of £55k, I nearly swerved off the road. “He is taking the p*ss, Jonathan!” I yelled down the phone. I was so incensed. I was trembling with anger. I couldn’t believe what I’d heard. I suppose it all started to fall apart for me from then on. I’d trusted Mr Dein to push the deal through.’

As a lifelong Arsenal fan, surely £10,000 a week (on top of £55,000 I might add) would come second in priority to playing for the club you so adore?

I know that for some money is priority, that some of the footballers from the poorer parts of Africa for example have a responsibility to provide for families that have to contend with serious poverty and famine. So of course an extra £10,000 will be a lot more beneficial. Of course £10,000 is relative to your own upbringing and wealth so to begrudge players (of a poor background) a move on the basis they only need the money may be slightly unethical, compared to someone who in all honesty may not need nearly as much.

In the case of Cole, the fact that he prioritised his bank account ahead of the club he loved (not to mention the way he went about it) resonates badly with fans of all clubs and it was perhaps the most contentious transfer in Premier League history.

Similarly the circumstances surrounding Michael Owen’s transfer to Real Madrid caused a lot of contempt from Liverpool fans after he was accused of holding the club to ransom over his own high wage demands. Not only that, he was sold at a cut price £8 million, costing the club the difference in his market value.

Despite growing up an Everton fan, Owen was nonetheless a fan favourite at Anfield, thus causing all the more confusion when he eventually departed. His comeuppance would come in the form of the Champions League arriving at Liverpool not even a year since his exit.

Frank Lampard is someone I’m surprised is still so popular at Stamford Bridge after his summer exploits at the hands of Inter Milan and Jose Mourinho.

Despite committing to Chelsea for another 5 years, Frank’s flirtation with Inter Milan over the summer surely had a part to play in his astronomical wage rise.

Quotes from Lampard admitting his admiration for the Milan club coupled with Jose Mourinho’s public coveting of the England midfielder served to force Chelsea’s hand further than it appeared they’d like.

Surprising, given Lampard’s incessant badge kissing at the Bridge.

As an Arsenal supporter I dream only of having the red and white shirt on, not the white of Madrid nor the red and blue of Barcelona. Despite my acknowledgement that these are perhaps in some respects bigger than Arsenal but I know that where I in the shoes of some of today’s footballers I would do my utmost to move to Arsenal and stay there.

I know in the cases of some players Barcelona or AC Milan might well be the clubs they supported as a child, as we have seen in the protracted Cristiano Ronaldo to Madrid saga (one I doubt is any where near over). But in his instance they were his boyhood club so I think a lot of people empathise with his longing for a move, especially when you consider that he has won all major trophies at Manchester United.

The massive wages on offer may have clouded some peoples views regarding the Ronaldo matter but I would maintain his desire to play in the royal white of Madrid outweighs that of filling his wallet.

This summer alone the term ‘dream club’ has become commonplace, though for different reasons.

Robbie Keane moved to Liverpool, a club he supported as a boy.

Dimitar Berbatov moved to Manchester United, the English and European Champions.

David Bentley moved to Spurs to have a chance of playing in the Champions League.

So of all these cases what would you consider concurrent with your own ideas of a dream move?

Would you prioritise the dream of playing for your boyhood club?

Does success take precedence over the club you play for?

Or do you think the chance of an extra £30,000 would be enough to take you away from your beloved team?

Adebayor this summer talked himself into a hole regarding wages, arguing last years 30 goal haul should give him parity with what Thierry Henry was earning whilst at the club. Now I’d imagine Adebayor’s agent was the main offender in this case, although it was very naive of Adebayor to believe his one good season was proof of his replacing of Henry. Seven more years like the last one and maybe you’ll have a point. Unfortunately I think it might be a bit longer before we forgive him – badge kissing and all. Yet for all the Togolese’ unsavoury conduct he was soon treated to a new £80,000 a week contract. Incredible.

The fact clubs are willing to pay such obscene amounts of money to these characters only accelerates the problem.

The idea of playing for Arsenal is a dream to me, let alone being paid to do so. I would have to say that the pride of having the cannon on my chest would far prevail over a few extra zeroes on the wage slip at the end of the week (How the hell do you spend £100,000 a week anyway?!), and I imagine the majority of you would agree with me (well not the cannon part but you get the gist).

That said, everyone has their price. Can you imagine what yours would be?

I know there are many variables involved in making such decisions, I.e. family etc but when eliminating such factors and making a decision based purely on money, success or club what would you choose?

A lot of questions but can you answer them all and honestly say you’d put your club over money?

A final thought comes from a question I asked a fellow Gooner not too long ago.

I posed a dilemma.

He was to take the penalty which would keep Barcelona alive in the Champions League final against Arsenal – to miss of course would mean

Barca would lose.

Champions League glory on the one hand.

Disdain and derision on the other.

His answer?

“I’d sky it”.

I could only smile in agreement.

This article is a submission for the Soccerlens 2008 Writing Competition; to participate, please read the details here. The competition is sponsored by Subside Sports (premier online store for football shirts) and Icons (official signed football jerseys).




Discussion - 12 Responses

  1. 31/10/2008 BD Condell

    Good article. My own view is that when it comes down to money (salaries) it has nothing to do with background etc. but only to do with what a player believes he is worth compared to what he knows others are being paid.

    In general I agree with what you say about the various players cited but I was unaware of the ‘numbers’ in terms of the Cole incident. If what he says is true I can understand his discontent. At the same time I can understand your feelings. I am on record (several times on this Blog) as being unforgiving regarding the Ronaldo saga.

    In my mind it comes down to how the player handles the situation. Honesty and sensitivity go a long way as compared to deception and ‘playing’ the media and, ultimately, I think that determines how we (fans) handle the outcome.

  2. 31/10/2008 Harasuke

    It i was taking a penalty vs lfc in the cl final, i’d try 2 score. why? because i’d be paid 2 win…n its dishonesty not 2 do it..even vs the club u support like hell.

    but even if lfc play in 2nd division, it’d still be a dreammove 2 go 2 them.

  3. 31/10/2008 jamie_sheffield_owl

    If i was playing Sheff Wednesday and man united came calling i’d tell them to f*ck right off! Its a passion you can’t explain good article

  4. You cant possibly put Owen in this catagory. He gave his all for Liverpool before finally moving to Madrid to win more medals. There wasnt any wage dispute or anything of that sort. The lad wanted to win more medals and he saw Real giving him that opportunity and he went for it. But of course his decision was later proven to be one he will regret. For some footballers its not just about playing its also about having something to show to your grandkids when they grow old. Rememeber Shearer and his interview. He said before he moved to Newcastle many big clubs wanted him but he chose the Geordies not because he loved the club it was because he saw the club was filled with ambitions and he foresaw he could win alot of medals there. But turned out he didnt win a single trophy. Its like that, Players like Ashley Cole and Ronaldo(Brazil) are A**holes but there are many other players who rather go to another club instead of the club they support just to win something. Money isnt everything for “some” i repeat SOME footballers. Honors play a part too.

  5. I think the case with Ashley Cole isn’t just about wanting more money. After all, in that deal that sent him to Chelsea, Gallas went the other way, and his complaints were similar to Cole’s, and Gallas isn’t hated nearly as much as Cole is. I think most fans understand that it is a business and won’t begrudge a player for moving to a better situation unless there are extenuating circumstances involved. Ashley Cole may have deserved more money, but the way he went about it left a lot to be desired. Meeting in secret with Jose Mourinho and Peter Kenyon reeked of dishonesty and nefariousness.

    Take Sol Campbell. After saying he would never play for Arsenal, not only did he go there, but he became one of their highest paid players. Something like that makes it personal to the fans, and I think that’s where the hatred comes from.

  6. 31/10/2008 Luke Smith

    I definitely agree with you Victor, that its most definitely a personal issue. However I think the Cole case was worthy of sizeable mention due to the manner in which he went about gaining his transfer. The bottom line is if he really cared so much for Arsenal, why leave based on an extra £5000 a week, when he already earned £55,000?

    The Sol Campbell case was one, I think Spuds fans understood – that he wanted to move to a club who regularly competed for trophies and Champions League football. The fact it was Arsenal obviously left deep wounds with their fans, though I’m not so sure it was for the massive wages. That came as part of Arsenal not paying a transfer fee to sign him.

  7. I actually think the Sol Campbell case was worse. He should have kept his mouth shut and not said that he would never go to Arsenal. Even if he wasn’t thinking about the fans, there’s no need to limit your options, right? If he hadn’t said that, then maybe Spurs fans would have been more understanding. I doubt it, since he was going to their biggest rival, but at least he would have went about it the right way.

    Take Silvestre. I thought hell would freeze over before Manchester United would sell a player to Arsenal. Still, Silvestre moved and no one at Manchester begrudged him for it. He wanted to play more and he figured he would have a better shot at Arsenal than at Manchester United. He didn’t pledge his undying loyalty to Manchester United. He didn’t say “I’ll never go to Arsenal.” He handled things the right way, and, while he may get some good-natured boos from Old Trafford, I’m sure he’ll get a nice reception if and when he goes back in a Gunners kit.

  8. Silly will probably get a cheer from United fans, which is ironic since he rarely got cheered as a United player.

    @Luke – when you’re making X per month and your colleagues are getting paid more for doing less, you might feel cheated and seek alternative employment. of course when you’re hearing 1/10000th of X per month (as we all are), it’s hard to understand.

    But think of football as a career and wage disagreements as a sign of self-worth issues and you’ll understand it better.

    Ashley Cole is still a muppet though…

  9. Great article well worth reading.

  10. You couldn't pry me away with a nuclear warhead. I might still date an arsenal fan, but give up United? Probably never.

    Having said that, it's different for me and different for the players. For the players it's a short career. The desire to win and earn a lot of money is fair, not every player is a fan and I think Ashley Cole from the beginning was more for himself than for the club.

  11. 31/10/2008 Luke Smith

    Granted Ahmed, everybody wants to be seen as a more valuable player, but what would it take for someone to lure you away from Old Trafford?

  12. Can we just clear up the Campbell issue? It wasnt JUST the fact he said he’d never sign for Arsenal; it wasnt JUST the fact he went to the team we all hate; it wasnt JUST the big wages he went for…………he delayed and delayed his decision and denied Spurs the chance to make £10-£15m, the going rate at the time for a class defender, if he’d been honest a year before and said he wanted to move. That was money he ‘owed’ Spurs who had developed him and turned him into a half-decent player, despite his rather troubled mental state.

    The Spurs fans reaction to Keane yesterday was another good example. Half the ground booed him (traitorous little sh*t, in effect the ‘real’ captain yet still showed no loyalty, moving as much for money as for honours, should have said he planned to leave so we would have kept Defoe) and half applauded him (6 years of good service, always gave 100%, moved to ‘club of his dreams’).

    Me? I did neither -I couldnt bring myself to boo him but I sure as hell wasnt going to applaud him off the pitch either.

    Ashley Cole? – Arsenal fans have every right to give him grief. So do England fans as he epitomises the greedy, couldnt-give-a-monkeys, self-centred attitude that led to us missing out on Euro 2008 and that Capello has worked hard to eradicate. And doing the dirty on Cheryl Cole with a slapper gives us all EVERY reason to hate him!

Developed by Football Media | All Content is under Copyright Protection | © 2006-2009 Soccerlens - Football News