The Goal-line Technology Debate: A Goalkeeper’s Perspective

So the FA are thinking about the need for goal-line technology after the goal that denied Fulham an equaliser against Middlesbrough on Saturday, which sort of resonated profoundly back to the blunders created by Roy Carroll in Manchester United’s ludicrous win over Tottenham back in 2005. Now apart from the above incidents, there are implications that every goalkeeper should take heed of especially if FIFA and other soccer governing bodies decide to introduce goal-line technology into the game.
Incidents such as the Fulham v Middlesbrough game show the need for game officials and organizers to be a little more stringent about the way a competitive match pans out. In this instance, I believe that Middlesbrough did not deserve the game, and even though Mark Schwarzer could not do much in this situation, Fulham were clearly denied the right to an equalizer. But, what the officials say…goes. But does it have to be that way? Could goal line technology really be a way of creating “fair play”?
Why goal-line technology will be good
- Teams who have scored a clear goal, can now be awarded points that they rightly deserve.
- Goalkeepers who blunder can be rightly caught out for their errors.
- Goal line technology will allow for officials to be more diligent and more confident in the way they rule the outcome of competitive matches.
- Goalkeepers will need to be more effective and alert, thus creating a better quality of play.
Potential problems
- Technology can go wrong. Not even the best technology in the world can be 100% accurate?
- Could slow down the pace of the game, as officials ponder over the results of the technology during game time.
- From a goalkeeping psychology perspective, it could further change the role of the competitive goalkeeper, as they must utilize extreme care and caution so as not to be caught out by any blunders that are signalled by the technology.
There are many other scenarios, but I feel that there will be some heated and ongoing discussion regarding goal line technology and it’s role in how the competitive football match pans out for quite some time. For goalkeepers, it could mean added and ongoing pressure to not create blunders in already highly competitive and nerve racking conditions during professional play. Overall, I feel that goal line technology will be a strong asset for the game, but it depends on how effectively it is utilized.
What do you all think about goal line technology, and how it will effect the role of the competitive goalkeeper?
Order your copy of Keeper Skool’s The G-Code today for $0! Includes our free “10 Weeks To Goalkeeping Success” course. Click Here.
- FIFA scraps plans for goal-line technology in favour of additional linesmen
- Video Evidence That Football Desperately Needs Video Technology
- Why is goal-line video technology taking so long?
- Hawk-Eye to make football faster, not slower
- Does Having Two More Referees On The Pitch Beat Video Technology?
Discussion - 6 Responses
Add Your Comment
Comments are moderated (our comments policy).











I saw them do an interveiw with the hawk-eye developer yesterday on Sky Sports News and he said that the goal line tech. would be instantaneous, i.e. as soon as the ball crosses the line the ref recieves a signal to his earpiece which confirms the ball has crossed the line. No need for a stop in play and accurate results. The problem though is that they have to make sure that it’s 100% accurate before it comes into play.
The goal line technology they’re looking at is similar to that used in tennis, I believe.
It doesn’t slow the game noticeably in tennis, and the ball is hitting near the line quite frequently in that sport.
In the first three games of the EPL this season the technology would’ve been used what, once? Healy’s goal vs. Boro. And it would’ve given a just result, maybe taken ten seconds to fix? I see no real negatives with the proposed technology.
It’s our interests vs theirs… dont u get it??
If technology is allowed to slowly erode their control of the game (I’m talking abt match officials) they are worried that one fine day, there would be a game between 2 teams with no man-in-black in the middle and men-with-flags at the sides.
They are worried that hawk-eye might one day spawn into hawk-control, hawk-offside-examiner etc etc.
They are resisting change so that THEY can control the game.
It’s all conspiracy I tell you!
HA!
i don’t really see how the third bullet point is a ‘potential problem’. Also, if instituted properly, i can’t see how it would slow the game down at all.And not even the best referees in the world can be 100% accurate either.
[…] http://soccerlens.com/the-goal-line-technology-debate-a-goalkeepers-perspective/2874/ […]