Maradona vs Pele – who was better?

Edson Arantes do Nascimento (Pele as he would later be known around the world) was often rated as the best player in the world. Only he and fellow legend Diego Armando Maradona, have received the honours by FIFA with the awards of officially being dubbed the greatest players in the history of the game. An ongoing debate among football fans to this day remains, who was better?

Pele is hailed in Brazil as a national hero and is an instrumental ambassador of the game. After scoring his 1,000th career goal he dedicated it to the poor children in the slums of Brazil. Maradona, despite his controversies, was one of the most skillful players to ever play the game and he won several trophies with Boca Juniors, Barcelona and Napoli. For his country he won 91 caps and scored 34 goals. Most notably one of the best ever was against England in a dazzling solo run (voted as Goal of the Century in an online debate conducted by FIFA in 2002), plus one of the most controversial in the same game now famously named as the “Hand of God”.

Pele on the other hand is the record all-time top scorer for his country (77 goals in 92 caps — amazing!), and is the only player in history to be part of three World Cup winning teams. He began smashing records at an early age though making his debut for Santos Futebol Clube at just 15, then making his debut for Brazil at 16 and winning his first World Cup at 17. Despite all the many offers he was given during his club career to join rich European clubs he remained loyal to Santos, playing for them for two decades. He did finally leave however in 1975 when he joined the all star squad of the New York Cosmos. He made 64 appearances for them and scored 37 times. In case you’re wondering he played 1,345 games for Santos and scored 1,265 goals (again amazing — the guy’s a machine!).

Maradona played in four World Cups for Argentina steering them to success in 1986 where he also collected the Golden Ball award as the tournaments best player. Despite his praises though he has faced some troubles during his life. He was banned from the game for 15 months in 1991 after he failed a drugs test for cocaine abuse in Italy. He was banned again during the 1994 World Cup, where he was sent home, this time for ephedrine. After he retired from the game in 1997 his weight ballooned and he suffered ill health. Again he was back on the cocaine. Since giving up drugs though he has become a television host in Argentina. Both men fathered children with women who have been left to raise them single-handedly, with little support from the leading figures of football.

Maradona did however achieve similar goal-scoring feats to Pele: 28 goals in 40 games (during his first spell at Boca Juniors, his second spell he scored 7 goals in 31 matches); 38 goals in 58 games (Barcelona); 115 goals in 259 games (Napoli). Despite his small size (1.65 m, 5 ft 5 in) Maradona had strength, could run with the ball and could withstand challenges, unlike some of today’s players who can’t even withstand challenges where there’s not even any contact! These main attributes of his are highlighted by his unbelievable goal in the 1986 World Cup. If you haven’t seen it, shame on you, but anyway think Lionel Messi but the original. Not only could he score goals with his unstoppable runs where he could take out a whole defence on his own but he was a team player too. With his strength and control he could often hold up the ball against a defender whilst a team-mate made the run through where he would thread it through to them.

Pele had an incredible eye for goal with deadly strike force and always glowed with confidence, even at such an early age. He was good in the air and was also a good team player, often laying on assists for his team-mates. Pele’s original technique and athleticism were highly praised whilst his dribbling ability and acute passing molded him into an all-round forward and natural goalscorer.

Who do you think was better between the two? Let me know by adding your comments below.

Also See:

Maradona vs. Pele: the Hand of God vs. the Right Hand of God.
My friend who played with Pele.
10 Great Football Player Rivalries.

What Now For England?
FIFA World Player of the Year 2007: Kaka, Ronaldo or Messi?

258 Comments

  1. Ken 30 November, 2007
  2. Steve Amoia 30 November, 2007
  3. manfred 30 November, 2007
  4. porky 85 1 December, 2007
  5. Kenny 1 December, 2007
  6. KyleAusGooner 1 December, 2007
  7. KyleAusGooner 1 December, 2007
  8. Andrei 1 December, 2007
  9. jose 16 January, 2008
  10. Karl 17 January, 2008
  11. sergio 18 January, 2008
  12. bocaj_91 7 February, 2008
  13. bocaj_91 7 February, 2008
  14. wes 19 February, 2008
  15. viejasrenga 18 March, 2008
  16. Stefano 3 April, 2008
  17. Jamal/Blanca 3 April, 2008
  18. zobondo 13 May, 2008
  19. jacky centiago 2 June, 2008
  20. Giovanni Chinnici 10 June, 2008
  21. Giovanni Chinnici 10 June, 2008
  22. burnfoot 23 June, 2008
  23. KEVIN PANI 14 July, 2008
  24. Dylan 8 September, 2008
  25. Gerard Onochie 31 October, 2008
  26. EPL 31 October, 2008
  27. Tapas 13 November, 2008
  28. nbaa 30 November, 2008
  29. PuL 18 December, 2008
  30. gentlegiant 27 December, 2008
  31. gentlegiant 27 December, 2008
  32. Muhammad Yasir 3 January, 2009
  33. gennaro 8 February, 2009
  34. pele is the best! 17 February, 2009
  35. Mahdi Yousif 18 February, 2009
  36. gennaro 20 February, 2009
  37. john 2 March, 2009
  38. tony p 4 March, 2009
  39. freedom66 13 March, 2009
  40. CATALAN 18 March, 2009
  41. KEVIN PANI 18 March, 2009
  42. KEVIN PANI 18 March, 2009
  43. Rob Mudriczki 26 March, 2009
  44. Alex 21 April, 2009
  45. Kassav 11 May, 2009
  46. Rude Boy 13 May, 2009
  47. carlos 17 May, 2009
  48. dave angel jr. 23 May, 2009
  49. jet 29 May, 2009
  50. Luciano 19 June, 2009
  51. Lucas 6 July, 2009
  52. Anil Trpathi 14 July, 2009
  53. . 23 July, 2009
  54. Pele was born for futbol like beethoven for music 1 August, 2009
  55. tip_legend 21 August, 2009
  56. Rick 24 August, 2009
  57. sab 26 August, 2009
  58. sab 27 August, 2009
  59. Some Futbol fan 12 September, 2009
  60. Some Futbol fan 12 September, 2009
  61. apache 17 September, 2009
  62. Pardeep 18 September, 2009
  63. jp 28 September, 2009
  64. ..jl17 11 October, 2009
  65. Scotty 30 October, 2009
  66. H 29 November, 2009
  67. Armando Tamayo 2 December, 2009
  68. Rodrigo 4 December, 2009
  69. Mike 5 December, 2009
  70. Krishna Mohapatra 7 December, 2009
  71. grrr 10 December, 2009
  72. Soumen Bhattacharjee 11 December, 2009
  73. AC Milan 17 December, 2009
  74. Jake 21 December, 2009
  75. Raj 23 December, 2009
  76. Raj 23 December, 2009
  77. Scotland Fan112 6 January, 2010
  78. Pele Forever 13 January, 2010
  79. Pele Forever 13 January, 2010
  80. acm 26 January, 2010
  81. eddy poletto 16 February, 2010
  82. georg t 16 February, 2010
  83. Stefano C 24 February, 2010
  84. Moraka Phatudi (South Africa) 25 February, 2010
  85. CV10 26 February, 2010
  86. Augusto 26 February, 2010
  87. GREAT MANGWENDE 3 March, 2010
  88. jj 13 March, 2010
  89. Rodr 13 March, 2010
  90. All 13 March, 2010
  91. Heartbreak Hotel 15 March, 2010
  92. wisam 16 March, 2010
  93. wisam 16 March, 2010
  94. Joao 18 March, 2010
  95. Luca 19 March, 2010
  96. Richard Stockton 20 March, 2010
  97. sb 26 March, 2010
  98. sb 26 March, 2010
  99. wisam 28 March, 2010
  100. sb 31 March, 2010
  101. Ali 2 April, 2010
  102. sb 4 April, 2010
  103. Jake Nazar 4 April, 2010
  104. sb 7 April, 2010
  105. clint 10 April, 2010
  106. sb 10 April, 2010
  107. Jaytay 11 April, 2010
  108. CHEN 11 April, 2010
  109. Amusing discussion here. 11 April, 2010
  110. sb 11 April, 2010
  111. Pele 11 April, 2010
  112. wisam 12 April, 2010
  113. sb 12 April, 2010
  114. sb 12 April, 2010
  115. sb 13 April, 2010
  116. sb 14 April, 2010
  117. sb 14 April, 2010
  118. CHEN 14 April, 2010
  119. Pele 14 April, 2010
  120. sb 14 April, 2010
  121. sb 14 April, 2010
  122. Jake 15 April, 2010
  123. sb 15 April, 2010
  124. sb 15 April, 2010
  125. sb 15 April, 2010
  126. sb 15 April, 2010
  127. sb 15 April, 2010
  128. Thom 16 April, 2010
  129. sb 16 April, 2010
  130. RSI 1943 16 April, 2010
  131. Joe 16 April, 2010
  132. CHEN 17 April, 2010
  133. CHEN 17 April, 2010
  134. CHEN 17 April, 2010
  135. sb 17 April, 2010
  136. sb 17 April, 2010
  137. sb 17 April, 2010
  138. sb 17 April, 2010
  139. pele 17 April, 2010
  140. CHEN 18 April, 2010
  141. sb 18 April, 2010
  142. sb 18 April, 2010
  143. sb 18 April, 2010
  144. CHEN 18 April, 2010
  145. CHEN 18 April, 2010
  146. sb 18 April, 2010
  147. sb 18 April, 2010
  148. CHEN 18 April, 2010
  149. sb 18 April, 2010
  150. JJ 18 April, 2010
  151. sb 19 April, 2010
  152. sb 19 April, 2010
  153. sb 19 April, 2010
  154. sb 19 April, 2010
  155. pele 19 April, 2010
  156. CHEN 20 April, 2010
  157. sb 20 April, 2010
  158. sb 20 April, 2010
  159. sb 22 April, 2010
  160. CHEN 23 April, 2010
  161. CHEN 23 April, 2010
  162. CHEN 23 April, 2010
  163. sb 23 April, 2010
  164. sb 23 April, 2010
  165. sb 24 April, 2010
  166. Pele 24 April, 2010
  167. Pele 24 April, 2010
  168. a.i 27 April, 2010
  169. Pele 27 April, 2010
  170. Sale Ars 9 May, 2010
  171. bb limbu 6 June, 2010
  172. mane 9 June, 2010
  173. Buzz 13 June, 2010
  174. gery 15 June, 2010
  175. keku writer 16 June, 2010
  176. chris 18 June, 2010
  177. ARNAB 18 June, 2010
  178. fraser 18 June, 2010
  179. Pele 19 June, 2010
  180. Bharat 19 June, 2010
  181. JJ 20 June, 2010
  182. Remmy 20 June, 2010
  183. HEMEL 20 June, 2010
  184. sb 21 June, 2010
  185. jOE 23 June, 2010
  186. jOE 23 June, 2010
  187. jOE 23 June, 2010
  188. sb 23 June, 2010
  189. jOE 24 June, 2010
  190. sb 24 June, 2010
  191. sb 24 June, 2010
  192. RASHEL KHAN 26 June, 2010
  193. sb 26 June, 2010
  194. MCS 26 June, 2010
  195. Pele 27 June, 2010
  196. ulises 27 June, 2010
  197. Nil 30 June, 2010
  198. varun 2 July, 2010
  199. sebastian 3 July, 2010
  200. morteza 3 July, 2010
  201. sb 4 July, 2010
  202. sujoy 5 July, 2010
  203. mAmun_bangladeshi 5 July, 2010
  204. Linhtran 6 July, 2010
  205. Mahesh 6 July, 2010
  206. hammed basheer 6 July, 2010
  207. Youhan 6 July, 2010
  208. D_Klin 7 July, 2010
  209. David 7 July, 2010
  210. Victor E.Hamlin 7 July, 2010
  211. sb 7 July, 2010
  212. Miguel 7 July, 2010
  213. dominic edwards 7 July, 2010
  214. dominic edwards 7 July, 2010
  215. Joha 8 July, 2010
  216. smit raval 8 July, 2010
  217. pratheesh 8 July, 2010
  218. nba 9 July, 2010
  219. drejke 11 July, 2010
  220. JiViX 13 July, 2010
  221. Arturo 14 July, 2010
  222. realist 14 July, 2010
  223. ahmad asaiti 15 July, 2010
  224. nick 16 July, 2010
  225. Reo 16 July, 2010
  226. sb 16 July, 2010
  227. self 17 July, 2010
  228. Alborz 17 July, 2010
  229. hffh 17 July, 2010
  230. mbye 18 July, 2010
  231. Olu Iluyo 19 July, 2010
  232. Olu Iluyomade 19 July, 2010
  233. sb 23 July, 2010
  234. sb 23 July, 2010
  235. sb 23 July, 2010
  236. joe .c 24 July, 2010
  237. sb 24 July, 2010
  238. Firas 25 July, 2010
  239. patrick 25 July, 2010
  240. Ricardo Garbiero 26 July, 2010
  241. joel 28 July, 2010
  242. nandu.... 29 July, 2010
  243. Eddie 1 August, 2010
  244. Brian Correa 4 August, 2010
  245. diego 5 August, 2010
  246. neel 6 August, 2010
  247. adi don 8 August, 2010
  248. Jim 13 August, 2010
  249. joel 16 August, 2010
  250. dibyo 17 August, 2010
  251. joel 17 August, 2010
  252. gus 20 August, 2010
  253. nandu.... 20 August, 2010
  254. hazz 30 August, 2010
  255. hazz 30 August, 2010
  256. dragon hunter 506794578 30 August, 2010
  257. hazzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz 30 August, 2010
  258. rita 30 August, 2010