Liverpool fan exposes media bias for Arsenal’s transfer record

Paul Tomkins has written an interesting article over at, in which he talks about tonight’s game at Anfield, the falsity of the notion that Liverpool are a 2-man team, and hypocrisy of the media in lauding Arsene Wenger’s transfer record while trashing that of Rafa Benitez.

Here are a few excerpts:

Arsenal are a young side. But Liverpool are also a fledgling team, and unlike Arsenal, the majority haven’t been part of the set-up for years. The 18-man squads involved in last Wednesday’s match had average ages of 25 (Arsenal) and 26 (Liverpool). By comparison with the other English teams involved, Manchester United’s was 27 and Chelsea’s 28. (Players’ ages correct to the last day of this season.) And of course, had Agger been fit to play instead of Hyypia, the average age of the Reds’ starting XI would come down by a full year.

While Arsenal have a few youngsters who are regularly on the bench —— Walcott, 19, and Bendtner, 20 —— they are not this team of raw kids as which they are portrayed. Almumia is 31, Gallas 30, Rosicky 27, Hleb 27, Toure 26, Eduardo 25, while van Persie and Adebayor are 24, and Eboue is nearly 24. Senderos is now 23, and Clichy will be 23 in the summer. The one truly young gem they have is Cesc Fabregas, who is about to turn 21.

The key difference is that most of Liverpool’s younger players are new to England this year, and part of a newer project, and as such are lagging behind Arsenal’s younger players in terms of adaptation. You will always get the exceptions to the rule like Torres, who adjusted very quickly (although has still improved), but the majority take time. Incredibly, none of Arsenal’s starting XI arrived into English football after 2005, and nine were either at Arsenal (or Chelsea, in Gallas’s case) in 2004. No wonder they play with a lot of understanding, of English football and of each other.

Contrast that with Liverpool, where six had arrived since 2006, and four of those since the start of 2007, and you can see the relativeness newness of Benítez’s project. Arsenal had two subs who arrived in 2006, but otherwise they all pre-dated 2005. In other words, Wenger had collected nearly all of his squad before or during Benítez’s first year. Liverpool’s bench contained four players signed in the last nine months.

While Fabregas and Clichy are now top-class top-level players, you need to wait at least two or three years to judge Benítez’s youngest signings, like Hobbs, Insua, Pacheco, Bruna, Nemeth and the impressive Plessis, who mixes midfield destruction with a sweet left foot.

One of my main bugbears is how Arsene Wenger’s mistakes in the transfer market somehow get overlooked.

While, as with Benítez, he has unearthed a lot of great players, he’s also bought a fair few failures and disappointments too. Stepanovs, Jeffers, Wright (Richard), Boa Morte, Diawara, Cygan, Wreh, Grimandi, Chukwunyelu Obinna, Danilevicious, Luzhny, van Bronckhurst and Baptista (bar one game, at Anfield) —— to name just a few; in all, a mixture of substandard players and a couple of talented ones who failed to settle.

Meanwhile, Wiltord and Reyes were £10m+ players who hardly set the world alight. With Benítez, a few cheap flops like Nunez, Josemi and Paletta (a mere kid) get brought up as if they are par for the course. You could add those three to the fee of Morientes and still not get what Arsenal paid for either Wiltord or Reyes.

Hard to disagree with some of the points Tomkins makes about Arsenal’s and Liverpool’s transfers. What do you guys think – is he right or wrong?

Hat tip to Arvin for pointing me to the article in the first place.

Ballack: Tottenham and Barnsley didn't beat Chelsea, we beat ourselves
The truth about shirt-swapping in football


  1. Max 8 April, 2008
  2. Tony 8 April, 2008
  3. Juan 8 April, 2008
  4. Ronin2009 8 April, 2008
  5. Juan 8 April, 2008
  6. Ricky 8 April, 2008
  7. Tony 8 April, 2008
  8. Roo 8 April, 2008
  9. Bobby bob 8 April, 2008
  10. Mitch 8 April, 2008
  11. Alan 8 April, 2008
  12. Alan 8 April, 2008
  13. Ash 8 April, 2008
  14. Juan 8 April, 2008
  15. gazzap 8 April, 2008
  16. Ricky 8 April, 2008
  17. Anthony Mkhizeeeeee 8 April, 2008
  18. Utsav 8 April, 2008
  19. Ole Gunner 8 April, 2008
  20. Ole Gunner 8 April, 2008
  21. Tony 8 April, 2008
  22. Juan 8 April, 2008
  23. Juan 8 April, 2008
  24. gooner chat 8 April, 2008
  25. Steve 8 April, 2008
  26. Jason 8 April, 2008
  27. Tony 8 April, 2008
  28. allpool 8 April, 2008
  29. 686 8 April, 2008
  30. everpool 9 April, 2008
  31. Andrew 9 April, 2008
  32. daveyparkender 9 April, 2008
  33. Winther 9 April, 2008
  34. Dave 9 April, 2008
  35. Tony 9 April, 2008
  36. browny 9 April, 2008
  37. truth speaker 9 April, 2008
  38. Arvin 9 April, 2008
  39. Gaga 10 April, 2008
  40. Gaga 10 April, 2008
  41. paulpy 10 April, 2008
  42. Dave 10 April, 2008
  43. Ahmed Bilal 10 April, 2008
  44. Liverpoo_Fan 10 April, 2008
  45. Tony 10 April, 2008
  46. Arvin 13 April, 2008
  47. Tony 13 April, 2008