Pato, Krkic, Balotelli or Kroos the European Rookie of the Year ?
In US sports they call it the ‘Rookie of the Year’ award, but there doesn’t appear to be an equivalent honour in European football. I know the PFA have their ‘Young Player of the Year’ award — but when you’ve got seasoned veterans like Cesc Fabregas and Cristiano Ronaldo in the running it hardly stacks up.
So I’ve created a list of ten authentic rookies, all young but also inexperienced before the 2007-08 season began back in August. All of them have impressed us this season — but do any deserve to be called the ‘Breakthrough Player of the Year’ ? Or did I forget someone ?
Firstly let me reveal the criteria I have applied to determine who qualifies as a breakthrough player this season and who does not. To be considered a breakthrough season, I figured the player must have appeared at least ten times in a top league. So there can be no argument about any of these players being just a ‘flash in the pan’.
I also thought that to be considered an original breakthrough, none of the candidates can have played ten or more times in a top league in any previous seasons. So — that means players like Alan McGregor (Rangers) and Manuel Neuer (Schalke 04) are instantly ruled out.
Bojan Krkic (Barcelona) — age 17. A stunning debut season in the Barcelona senior squad during which he’s played in 27 matches and scored 8 goals. He also scored the winner in Germany against Schalke 04 in the Champions League QF 1st leg.
Joe Hart (Manchester City) — age 21. Took over as Sven-Goran Eriksson’s first choice keeper in September and held the position down all season. Capable of stunning saves and ultra consistent, Fabio Capello has spoken of his as a future senior England international.
David Wheater (Middlesbrough) — age 21. Now established as a first choice for his local club, Middlesbrough sold Jonathan Woodgate because they were so confident Wheater could fill the breach. Has not disappointed and was similarly singled out by Capello as a future full international. Scored three goals for Boro and shown ability to play out from the back.
Lorenzo De Silvestri (Lazio) — age 19. Played 23 games as a full-back after being switched from a midfielder in the Primavera squad. Scored his first goal for the club in the Coppa Italia in December and has earned rave reviews for his ability to get forward as well as defend.
Toni Kroos (Bayern Munich) — age 18. Following his Golden Ball award as the best player at last summer’s Under-17 World Cup, Kroos has lived up to Bayern fans’ expectations. In just eight games he has contributed two assists in the Bundesliga and even scored the last minute winner away to Red Star in the UEFA Cup, shortly after setting up another in a decisive nine-minute cameo.
Marek Hamsik (Napoli) — age 20. After two seasons in Serie B with Brescia, Hamsik made the step up to the top flight and has flourished as 8 goals in 35 games for Napoli from midfield suggests. He also found time to score two goals for Slovakia during the season and looks set for a big future.
Esteban Granero (Getafe) — age 20. Granero has blossomed during a one-year loan from Real Madrid – playing 24 La Liga games, and firing two goals. He’s demonstrated the ability to peform in the big matches and has been a star for Getafe in their run to the Copa del Rey final and Uefa Cup quarter finals.
Mario Balotelli (Inter) — age 18. Really hit the headlines in January with his brace against Juventus in the Coppa Italia. Had also scored two against Reggina prior to that but since the start of April has begun to see more Serie A action – delivering two further goals in eight total appearances, most from the bench.
Alexandre Pato (Milan) — age 18. I’ve bent the rules slightly to allow Pato in because he did play 10 matches for Internacional last season. But his first season at Milan has been the breakout campaign. In 15 Serie A games, 8 goals is a stunning return for a precocious teenager who still has some growing up to do. Scoring on his Brazil debut also adds to the feeling that he can become a fairytale player.
Yoann Gouffran (Caen) — age 21. The 2006-07 Ligue 2 Player of the Season has coped with the step up and led his side to a respectable mid-table position in France. In 33 games he has managed 9 goals — of all types, with both feet.
Written by Simon Barlow, a professional sports writer who blogs about Euro 2008 betting at Betfair.
Topics: Bundesliga, English Premier League, La Liga, Ligue 1, Serie A



Football News 24/7
Wheres Anderson.(man united)
May 1st, 2008 @ 08:24Anderson is shite. Bojan was quiet during the ManU game whilst Pato was selfish against Arsenal. But great things can be expected from Pato.
May 1st, 2008 @ 09:28wat bout walcott
May 1st, 2008 @ 12:42Yeah anderson was shite
Ask Stevie Me or Fibreglass,
May 1st, 2008 @ 13:26Definetly Bojan is the man to win this trophy. What abouty Nani (manu)
May 1st, 2008 @ 13:33Nani And Andy took care ov arsenal,liverfool and barcelona
i didnt c bojan doing shit all against man u but run around..
May 1st, 2008 @ 13:50Raed ur a fool,,anderson owns..lol yea jus ask stevie g and fiberglass,,
Nani made his debut for the Sporting first team in the 2005-06 season, in which he made 32 appearances and scored five goals. That would be his ‘breakout’ season.
Anderson in 2006-07, despite breaking his leg managed to appear in 15 games, scoring two goals.
So neither qualifies under the ten match criteria, as stated above.
May 1st, 2008 @ 13:571stly…anderson is not shite.
May 1st, 2008 @ 13:592ndly..”I also thought that to be considered an original breakthrough, none of the candidates can have played ten or more times in a top league in any previous seasons”
So anderson and nani and walcott are ruled out
the award has got to go 2 bojan..hes sensational. i think gr8 things can be expected from all of these players
Yeah I’m surprised Anderson’s not on this list, I didn’t think he’d played many games for Porto, because of his broken leg. From your list though, I think Pato is the clear winner. Bojan has indeed been a shining light in a poor season for Barca, but Pato looks in a class of his own.
I haven’t seen many of the others play, though. Balotelli looks quality.
May 1st, 2008 @ 14:56I’m a City fan but I don’t know how anyone can say Anderson is shite. He reminds me so much of Edgar Davids with his tigerish nature and dribbling ability.
May 1st, 2008 @ 16:27Hamsik’s excellent. He’ll most probably be at a big European team in 5 years. Krkic has done very well as well.
May 1st, 2008 @ 16:44I don’t follow the Premiership that closely, so i can’t say anything about the English players mentioned in the article, but Pato indeed looks like the real deal.
Krkic is also impressive but i think Pato has the pedigree to become a complete forward.
Kroos must indeed be special too, because Bayern is not a club to flaunt teenagers just for the sake of it.
If some 18year old guy can break in their first squad, he must have some serious game.
May 1st, 2008 @ 17:16How about Giovani Dos Santos? Stevan Jovetic? Ivan Rakitic? Karim Benzema?
May 2nd, 2008 @ 02:05Giovanni Dos Santos was not nearly as good as his counterpart Bojan this year. Bojan all the way. I’d say he’s doing pretty good when he is only 17, and has been one of the better players on his team.
May 2nd, 2008 @ 03:28I’m surprised you didn’t put Alberto Paloschi up there. While many people had heard of these players before this season Paloschi has been a real surprise. He came out of nowhere and stepped up in front of players like poor Gilardino.
May 4th, 2008 @ 01:52Ryan Babel? I think Pato is really really over-rated he is a poor player and shouldnt be playing for a top club.
May 5th, 2008 @ 19:32sorry i forgot Babel was playing for Ajax last season!
May 5th, 2008 @ 19:33Of that list I’d have to say Krkic, he has achieved the most this season in my opinion and shown the most promise. Joe Hart has also impressed me immensely. Balotelli and Pato for honourable mentions.
May 5th, 2008 @ 21:37Off that list i ould have to say Bojan though Pato and Kroos have also been very impressive
May 6th, 2008 @ 07:23sebastian giovinco is the new zola
May 9th, 2008 @ 12:46Walcott Pato Nasri
October 1st, 2008 @ 18:23