Comments on: Beye wins red-card appeal – shouldn’t Newcastle get all 3 points too? http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/ Football News Fri, 10 Feb 2012 21:17:04 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v= By: Zohar http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104652 Zohar Fri, 24 Oct 2008 10:05:34 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104652 The FA were wrong here. Baye barely touched the ball, but still knocked down Rhobinho who could have easily scored had he stayed up on his feet. The post it self is provoking - but that's what gets us to read it ;-) The FA were wrong here. Baye barely touched the ball, but still knocked down Rhobinho who could have easily scored had he stayed up on his feet.

The post it self is provoking – but that’s what gets us to read it ;-)

]]> By: Wigan Blue http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104613 Wigan Blue Thu, 23 Oct 2008 21:48:45 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104613 I've voiced my opinion elsewhere on this. Even if it was a penalty (and I have serious doubts about that), Beye didn't deserve to march. The ref should have that discretion. Same applies to Zabaleta. Never touched the man, took the ball as cleanly as you like, and got sent off. Why on earth shouldn't we have appealed that one? - because it certainly changed the game and gave Liverpool an open door. As for giving Newcastle the 3 points - ha! They were lucky as hell to come away with one, and they know it... I’ve voiced my opinion elsewhere on this. Even if it was a penalty (and I have serious doubts about that), Beye didn’t deserve to march. The ref should have that discretion.

Same applies to Zabaleta. Never touched the man, took the ball as cleanly as you like, and got sent off. Why on earth shouldn’t we have appealed that one? – because it certainly changed the game and gave Liverpool an open door.

As for giving Newcastle the 3 points – ha! They were lucky as hell to come away with one, and they know it…

]]> By: patrick http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104612 patrick Thu, 23 Oct 2008 21:21:37 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104612 Must admit I thought it was a daft idea, but then I got to thinking that if they reallocated points for dodgy decisions and applied it over the last 15 seasons the Scum would have all those titles taken off them. Must admit I thought it was a daft idea, but then I got to thinking that if they reallocated points for dodgy decisions and applied it over the last 15 seasons the Scum would have all those titles taken off them.

]]> By: biffa http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104611 biffa Thu, 23 Oct 2008 21:20:47 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104611 You can't blame Styles just because he was at the wrong angle to view it properly. What the hell is wrong with another referee calling the decision from a tv monitor, afterall there are millions doing it at home. Personally I wish he had stayed on, we were much better against 11 men than we were against 10! You can’t blame Styles just because he was at the wrong angle to view it properly. What the hell is wrong with another referee calling the decision from a tv monitor, afterall there are millions doing it at home.
Personally I wish he had stayed on, we were much better against 11 men than we were against 10!

]]> By: p http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104604 p Thu, 23 Oct 2008 20:20:15 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104604 tbh we can't say the decision "cost us three points" - we don't know whether the team was galvanised after the sending off/goal..... The way we played was typical 10 against 11 and we were still lucky........ tbh we can’t say the decision “cost us three points” – we don’t know whether the team was galvanised after the sending off/goal….. The way we played was typical 10 against 11 and we were still lucky……..

]]> By: John http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104603 John Thu, 23 Oct 2008 20:18:13 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104603 The point is that YET AGAIN, a professional referree who gets paid a higher than average salary has been incompetent. If you or I made a crucial error of judgement, we'd at least get a warning, or worse, the boot! Rob Styles is a disgrace with a track record to prove it. The man should be consigned to sunday league soccer where, if he messed up like he has this season, his prize would be a black eye, or worse! The point is that YET AGAIN, a professional referree who gets paid a higher than average salary has been incompetent.

If you or I made a crucial error of judgement, we’d at least get a warning, or worse, the boot!

Rob Styles is a disgrace with a track record to prove it.

The man should be consigned to sunday league soccer where, if he messed up like he has this season, his prize would be a black eye, or worse!

]]> By: MCFC4LIFE http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104602 MCFC4LIFE Thu, 23 Oct 2008 20:07:51 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104602 What a load of nonsense. Who cares if he was unfairly dismissed, a cards a card and i believe it should stay that way. Even if he hadnt have been carded who says newcastle would have gone on to win the game without a penalty anyway? To even think about changing the score is ludacris and you should be shot for even trying to put the idea into peoples heads. Plenty of wrong decisions are made every game such as the penalty at man city wigan but who says city would of won if wigans penalty hadnt of happened? You idiot What a load of nonsense.

Who cares if he was unfairly dismissed, a cards a card and i believe it should stay that way. Even if he hadnt have been carded who says newcastle would have gone on to win the game without a penalty anyway?

To even think about changing the score is ludacris and you should be shot for even trying to put the idea into peoples heads.

Plenty of wrong decisions are made every game such as the penalty at man city wigan but who says city would of won if wigans penalty hadnt of happened?

You idiot

]]> By: RB http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104600 RB Thu, 23 Oct 2008 19:24:47 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104600 The FA did not say the foul wasn't valid, just the red card. The red card was most likely given for denying a goal scoring opportunity and the FA didn't agree, with the ref, that all the factors were in play to warrant the red card. The foul and penalty kick would still apply. All cards are reviewed and punishment is applied based on the review of the misconduct report and the severity of the foul. The FA did not say the foul wasn’t valid, just the red card. The red card was most likely given for denying a goal scoring opportunity and the FA didn’t agree, with the ref, that all the factors were in play to warrant the red card. The foul and penalty kick would still apply. All cards are reviewed and punishment is applied based on the review of the misconduct report and the severity of the foul.

]]> By: beyethegreat http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104599 beyethegreat Thu, 23 Oct 2008 19:21:04 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104599 http://www.nufcblog.com/2008/10/23/newcastle-news/beye-red-card-overturned/#comment-210230 http://www.nufcblog.com/2008/10/23/newcastle-news/beye-red-card-overturned/#comment-210230

]]> By: beyethegreat http://soccerlens.com/beye-wins-red-card-appeal-shouldnt-newcastle-get-all-3-points-too/14428/#comment-104598 beyethegreat Thu, 23 Oct 2008 19:20:47 +0000 http://soccerlens.com/?p=14428#comment-104598 its a shame we didnt get the decision but to say but to say we should get the 3 points is ridiculous and like ed said its just good to have him for the derby game btw ed harrisson in case you didnt know has his own website its a shame we didnt get the decision but to say but to say we should get the 3 points is ridiculous and like ed said its just good to have him for the derby game
btw ed harrisson in case you didnt know has his own website

]]>